| Platinum | Pizza Palace #2 |
| Gold | Pizza Palace Restaurant |
| Silver | Bella Nonna |
| Bronze | Antonella's Italian Ristorante |
| Top Pick | Elizabeth's Pizza Hope Mills |
| Top Pick | Gusto Napoletano Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Little Italy Pizzeria and Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Luigi's Italian Restaurant & Bar |
| Top Pick | Pierros Italian Bistro |
| Top Pick | Sammio's Italian Restaurant Hopemills |