| Platinum | Brooklyn Pizzeria |
| Gold | Elizabeth's Pizza Hope Mills |
| Silver | Elizabeth's Pizza Skibo |
| Bronze | Pizza Palace Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Bella Nonna |
| Top Pick | Gusto Napoletano Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Hungry Howie's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Mancini New York Deli & Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Mellow Mushroom Fayetteville |
| Top Pick | Pierro's Italian Bistro |