| Platinum | A&Y Auto Sale, LLC |
| Gold | Carmax |
| Silver | Kingdom Auto Sales |
| Bronze | Sell Your Car Today |
| Top Pick | Brown's Auto World |
| Top Pick | Cross Creek Lincoln-Mercury-Subaru Inc |
| Top Pick | Drivetime Used Cars |
| Top Pick | Fayetteville Used Cars |
| Top Pick | Haynes Automotive |
| Top Pick | Wayne's Wheels |