| Platinum | Eggs Up Grill |
| Gold | Circa 1800 |
| Silver | Metro Diner |
| Bronze | Blue Moon Cafe |
| Top Pick | Bees and Boards Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Continental Cafe |
| Top Pick | J K's Family Restaurant & Deli |
| Top Pick | Marybills Cafe |
| Top Pick | Paradise Acres |
| Top Pick | Uptown's Chicken & Waffles |