| Platinum | Captain Jerry's Seafood Family |
| Gold | Peaden's Seafood & Catering |
| Silver | Melvin's by The Riverside |
| Bronze | North Atlantic Fish & Chips |
| Top Pick | Bamm-Bamms Fresh Seafood Market |
| Top Pick | Crab Du Jour |
| Top Pick | Metro Diner |
| Top Pick | Ramsey Street Seafood Market |
| Top Pick | Tasty Crab |
| Top Pick | Twin Peaks |